Topps 1963 All-Star Rookie Cup Team: Part 1 – the Cards

Before I start let me note that the cards that the All-Star Rookie Cup cards that show up in a Topps set represent the squad for the previous season.

In short it means that the 1963 All-Star Rookie Cup Team is honored in 1964 Topps set.

Ok enough legalese.

The most noteworthy of the 1963 All-Star Rookie Cup card belongs to Pete Rose. I am not going to cover this card here, but if you want to read a terrific heartfelt column check out the posting Wax Pack Gods which can be found here.

1964 Topps #109 Rusty Staub

Instead we will venture down the rabbit hole that is the 1964 Topps Rusty Staub card. What is not to love here, a six-time all-star on a card that boldly screams COLTS at the top of the card. Rusty’s cap with the .45s logo completes the franchise original “Colt .45s” nickname. Rusty Staub was likely still a teenager when this photo was taken – He did not turn 20 until just prior to opening day in 1964. He has at least 286 of his 292 career Home Runs in front of him. Le Grand Orange would go on to become an original Expo and would later win an NL pennant with the New York Mets.

1963 was the fifth time that Topps presented the awards that started in 1959. Starting in 1961 the Rookie Cup Award winner cards were identical to base cards except that they possess an “icon” of the trophy. Notice that the trophy has an engraving –  TOPPS 1963 ALL-STAR ROOKIE. There you have it, the 1964 card features the 1963 team.


1964 Topps #109 Rusty Staub (b-side)

Flipping the card over we see that in the last sentence Topps mentions Staub’s Rookie All-Star accomplishment. In addition to his MLB debut season numbers we also get Rusty’s impressive 1962 professional debut 23 HR, 93 RBI, and .293 BA over 140 games.

One of the things that we once again are not getting with 2018 Topps cards is a Trivia Question or cartoon. But in 1964 Topps had them – in fact Topps even went to the trouble to hide the answers from us. Fortunately this card was much loved by a previous owner, who has gone to the trouble of scratching off the answer and we now know that the last AL player to have a four homer game was the Indians Rocky Colavito in 1959. Well, that was true in 1964 anyway.

Rocky’s big game occurred on June 10, 1959 at Baltimore’s Memorial Stadium where the Indians defeated the Orioles in an 11-8 slugfest. On the card a funny cartoon shows a pitcher getting shelled – this is symbolic of either Starter Jerry Walker or relievers Arnie Portocarrero or Ernie Johnson.

The artist hyphenated COLA-VITO, making Rocky Colavito sound like some sort of fancy new energy drink.  Rocky is now 84 years old and as of his 2008 SABR Bio lives in Bernville, Pennsylvania — not far from Phungo Headquarters.

It has been 54 years since the Rusty Staub card was produced and the trivia answer is no longer current. If this cartoon quiz was produced today the answer would be Josh Hamilton. Other junior circuit members that have accomplished the fete since Colavito are Carlos Delgado and Mike Cameron. The most recent National Leaguer to hit four is JD Martinez,  who tagged the LA Dodgers pitching for the quadruple during a Diamondbacks  13-0 victory this past September.

Subset Checklist

73  Jimmy Hall OF
85  Pete Ward 3B
109  Rusty Staub 1B
125  Pete Rose 2B
130  Gary Peters LHP
168  Al Weis SS
330  Tommy Harper OF
412 Ray Culp RHP
435  Vic Davalillo OF
457  Jesse Gonder C
I realize this is pretty vanilla but  I have been deep diving All-Star Rookie teams a bit lately and found some interesting and want to open with a posting that gives some background on the original card. I anticipate this being the first of three postings on the 1963 Topps All-Star Rookie Cup Team.
Topps All-Star Rookie Cup Team
For more background on the origins of the Topps All-Star team I have written a posting at my personal blog Phungo.  The article can be found here.

Sources and Links

Phungo 1963 Topps Rookie Cup Index

Phungo Game Dated Cards Index

SABR Bio Rocky ColavitoJoseph Wancho

Wax Pack Gods

Baseball Card Database


Baseball Almanac

Author: phungo2008


6 thoughts on “Topps 1963 All-Star Rookie Cup Team: Part 1 – the Cards”

  1. Three White Sox on the list. Peters would have an excellent career and Ward was above average. Al Weis had his shinning moment in the 69 WS for Mets. I never quite got the appeal of Topps’ scratch off trivia questions. Tommy Harper holds several “all-time” Seattle Pilots records. “Tailwind Tommy” was anything but vanilla for the legions of Pilots fans. Very enjoyable post!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: