A True Value or hardware disorder?

In 1986, one could head to the local True Value hardware store to buy a box of nails or a toilet plunger and emerge with a folded, sealed, four-card panel featuring three players from the “True Value Super Stars Collector Series.”

The oddly packaged set features a fourth card on the panel that serves as a sweepstakes entry form with a picture of a True Value product on the opposite side. This advertisement card forms the back of the pack while one of the player cards comprises the front.

The cards are perforated to allow for each card to be individually detached. Of course, the panel could be kept intact, but one of the cards would be separated by the advertisement.  Furthermore, the panel size is too big for a three-pocket, Hostess style page. An obsessive purist could leave the cards sealed, content in knowing two more cards reside inside, but the most logical thing to do is detach the cards.

This is exactly what I did this summer after purchasing the 10 different card folios at a local card shop.  After 33 years, the adhesive beneath the back flaps was firmly set.  I needed to use a putty knife to detach the flaps.  Once opened, the 2-1/2″ x 3-1/2″ cards had to be carefully separated to prevent tears. The front card must be at least 1/32 of an inch wider than the cards from the inside, since it fits very snugly in a standard 9-pocket page.

It goes without saying that once you have the 30 cards separated you are left with a crappy set.  These cards were produced by Michael Schechter Associates (MSA), who only had a MLBPA licensing agreement.  If MSA sounds familiar to you, you may know the name from these ubiquitous discs of the mid-1970s.

The lack of an MLB license results in mostly “head and shoulder” shots without cap logos. (Andre Dawson is shown from the waist up.)  The same images are used on numerous odd ball sets of the era.  The photos are small and the red, white and blue framing is overwrought.

The set does contain many all-time greats. There are 15 Hall of Famers including Tom Seaver on the White Sox, Reggie Jackson on the Angels, and Gary Carter with the Mets (but wearing an Expos cap). Fans of the Indians, Rangers, and Giants will not find a home team hero in the set. 

My collection of “junk wax” era, odd ball sets continues to grow, which begs the question: Why do I continue to add these unattractive cards with recycled images?  Perhaps I’m genetically predisposed to own every known image of “Mr. Mariner,” Alvin Davis.  Or, perhaps my essential cheapness won’t let me turn down bargain priced cards.  Both could be true, but I believe the answer lies in my slow but steady descent into hoarding syndrome. 

Author: Tim Jenkins

Sports memorablilia collector with Seattle teams emphasis. HOF autographs, baseball cards and much more. Teacher for over 30 years. Attended games at 35 different MLB parks.

6 thoughts on “A True Value or hardware disorder?”

  1. As another junk wax oddball hoarder (who’s thankful that no Giants are in this set since it’s kind of brutal) I’ve come to realize that most of the appeal of these commercial/retail sets is in the non-baseball part of the design. Seeing logos for stores and products that no longer exist and being reminded of what life in the US was like before corporate monoculture took over.

    Oddballs from my stores remind me of where I used to shop with my mom. Oddballs from a store I’ve never heard of meanwhile serve to remind me h0w big the US used to be. I never saw Hills, Woolworths, Revco, Circle-K, etc. as a kid. Sometimes I’d see one in a movie. But I have cards from there now all of which include the company logo and that beats the pants off of yet another color parallel exclusive that could be found at Walmart/Target/ToysRUs.

    I did resist the 1970s MSA discs for a long time until I saw the advertisements on the backs and yeah. Same idea. they don’t speak to me in terms of any nostalgia factor but they describe a retail environment that is familiar in the sense that it’s in my earliest memories even though I don’t actually really remember any of it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. If one goes back far enough we can add Tobacco Cards to those that have identical images marketed by multiple companies in varied locales. The cards are differentiated by the advertising information on the back .

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I have convinced myself that I collect cards of all types because someone thought at the time “This is a good idea” or at least “Someone wants this.” And to some people it may have been their introduction to cards or their favorite set. And those things need to be preserved. I mean, I even have a 1943 MP & Co. Johnny Mize.

    As for storing the complete unfolded panel, I’d probably put it in a 1-pocket page with an actual 8×10 or similar sized card behind it. That’s how I have panels stored now that I don’t want to cut up (like a 1981 Squirt Panel). There are 2-pocket pages for 5×7 cards, but what someone needs to make is a vertical 2-pocket page (4×10 or something like that). Ultra-PRO, what are you waiting for?


  3. I believe your possible hoarding disorder is best explained by a line from the inimitable Daffy Duck, “Mine, mine, all mine!”.


Leave a Reply to artiezillante Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: