Brace, Conlon, McWilliams, McCarthy. McCarthy? Most card collectors and hardcore baseball fans have heard of, or encountered, the photography of George Brace, Charles Conlon and Doug McWilliams. For some reason, J.D. McCarthy has slipped through the cracks.
He shouldn’t have. McCarthy, from near Detroit, was a top level photographer, clicking away product that players used as postcards to answer fan mail or promote their bowling alleys and pizza parlors (McCarthy entries are scattered throughout the Standard Catalog), and that Topps used on a freelance basis. McCarthy archives had made it through various hands, and the bottom of the collection ended up with Bob Lemke, formerly of Krause Publications and one-time editor of the Standard Catalog. He wrote about it here.
Bob makes the point that the collection went through multiple owners, and, by the time it got to him, had been picked over, the Hall of Famers and big stars had disappeared. Which leads me to this post.
Back in 1986, I was visiting Cooperstown and, of course, Baseball Nostalgia. The shop, co-owned by inaugural Burdick Award Winner Mike Aronstein, was in its old location, at what is now the batting range. I picked up my usual odds and ends, like the current San Francisco Giants yearbook, and this little gem. (I’d always been under the impression that Sports Design Products was an Aronstein company, but Andrew Aronstein assured me it was not.)
I had never heard of McCarthy, and had no idea of what would be contained within this plastic box, but, man, what’s inside was a marvel then, and still is now. It’s a 24-card set, matte-finish (if not matte, non-glossy), with brilliant photos and a simple, 1969 Topps design. SDP clearly had some big plans for the superstar portraits of McCarthy, hoping to get on board the card boom. Seemingly those dreams were never realized.
Here’s the entirety of the set:
An up close look at these two beauts:
(The backs have little to offer, but I know you “card back” guys care.)
While still cheap in price, the McCarthy set is high in aesthetic value. Track one down.
I have this McCarthy set. Plus hundreds of his postcards
LikeLiked by 3 people
Nice. I’m successfully avoiding the postcard rabbit hole.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love them too much. Multiple binders full
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi, Mark. Do you have any postcards from Mel Bailey or Brook Treakle?
LikeLike
Nice!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Does anyone know why Robin Roberts is in a Yankee uniform?
LikeLiked by 1 person
In the New Bill James Historical Abstract (the one written around 2000 with rankings based on various measures of win shares), James mentions that Roberts was sold to the Yankees after the 1961 season. Baseball-reference confirms that he was “on” the Yankees from October 1961 until May 1962, although he didn’t play in a regular season game for them.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yeah, it’s one of the great instances of a guy never actually playing for a team but getting a card with them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Because he went to spring training with them in 1962 and was cut early in the season.
LikeLike
I remember Renata Galasso advertising this set for sale in the early 1980s.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Always loved JD’s photography. I just ordered a set on eBay.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great!
LikeLike
That’s a nice article and an attractive set. I have collect McCarthy’s 1969 Seattle Pilots photos, and have one of his Pilots contact sheets. Have always been a fan of his photography!
LikeLiked by 2 people
I have a Bob Locker and Ray Oyler postcards. Do you have other post cards? I’ve seen the images of at least 8 other Pilots.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t have any postcards and am trying my best to resist!
LikeLike
There are two Locker postcard variations (McCarthy logo left and McCarthy logo right) and the one Oyler postcard. I realize I have two McCarthy contact sheets, not one. Players pictured (several with different poses) are Oyler, McNertney, Locker, Comer, Bouton, Gil, Gosger, Ranew, Tommy Davis.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks for the tip Jeff. I have ordered a set.
LikeLiked by 1 person