When my first book, The Kansas City A’s and the Wrong Half of the Yankees, came out in 2007, I wasn’t as focused on getting book-related cards as I would be for Split Season 1981. In all fairness, it was easy pickings to find sets from 1981 that I didn’t have – Topps Foldouts, Scratch-offs, Coca-Cola, Stickers, Giant Photo Cards, Drake’s, Squirt, Kellogg’s. (Here’s the post). Not as easy for the A’s book.
As I often do, I found myself at Baseball Nostalgia in Cooperstown and came across a 1955 Rodeo Meats reprint set, a 1976 issue. Affordable ($4) and filled with guys I had been researching and writing about. The back of the header card explains the originals better than I can:
It’s not that exciting a set, but fun to have:
The backs are plain and informative:
But, hold on:
The originals are in glorious ’50’s color!
The 1955 set, coinciding with the A’s arrival from Philadelphia, has 38 different players with one error – Bobby Shantz’, one spelled “Schantz,” the other “Shantz.” There are players with two backgrounds – Cloyd Boyer (blue and pink), Joe DeMaestri (pea and light greens), Arnie Portocarrero (pink and yellow), Bill Renna (dark and light pinks), Wilmer Shantz (orange and purple. Why couldn’t they get those Shantz brothers done correctly?), Elmer Valo (yellow and purple) and Bill Wilson (yellow and purple). All in all there are 47 cards.
The 1956 set was reduced to 13 cards. The backs are different too. Here’s a 1955 back, featuring a scrapbook offer):
If you’re thinking that these are real beauties and that you’d like to pick a few up, beware! They are super pricey. As a result, I’ll settle for my black and whites.
Disappointing, sure, but not as disappointing as being a KC A’s fan and watching them trade all your favorite players to the Yankees, or, worse, parking them until New York called them back.
One hundred years after the 1919 World Series, baseball
cards of the players involved in the Black Sox Scandal continue to attract
Beckett Media’s Mike Payne and Andy Broome compiled a
comprehensive list of every baseball card featuring one of the “Eight Men Out”
from their playing careers, ranging from about 1908 to 1920. The list was
printed in the August 2017 issue of Beckett Vintage Collector magazine
and reprinted in the SABR
Black Sox Scandal committee newsletter by permission.
Some of those cards, like Shoeless Joe Jackson’s 1914
Cracker Jack card, regularly sell for hundreds or even thousands of dollars at
online auctions. Others, like Fred McMullin’s only individual card — a 1915
Zeenut made when he was still in the minor leagues with the Los Angeles Angels
— are virtually impossible to find today.
“I still receive a number of requests for Black Sox cards
and material, but I suspect that many of these inquiries are from flippers,”
longtime vintage card dealer and SABR member Mark Macrae told Beckett. “The
highest demand has always been for Jackson. The toughest is McMullin. The most
plentiful, and the player that seems to hang around the longest in stock, is
By virtue of having the longest major-league career, Cicotte has more cards (70) of the 268 in Beckett’s list than any other Black Sox player. His cards range from a 1909 supplemental card published by the Boston Herald to a 1920 D327 card issued in packages of Holsum Bread.
Macrae says one of the most sought-after sets, and one of the least expensive for casual collectors, is the 1919-21 W514 strip card series that included seven of the eight Black Sox (all except McMullin). Beckett offers recommendations with the most “affordable” cards for each player and the W514s fit the bill for Buck Weaver, Happy Felsch, Lefty Williams, and Swede Risberg. For Cicotte, his T205 card issued in 1911 is relatively easy to find and sometimes sells for less than $100. Chick Gandil’s T206 card from 1910 — in the same set as the most valuable baseball card in the world, the iconic Honus Wagner card — is regarded as the Black Sox first baseman’s most affordable card, according to Beckett.
Most Shoeless Joe Jackson cards could hardly be considered
“affordable,” usually selling for anywhere between $1,000 and $500,000. Beckett
also includes a list of “dream” cards for each player, and Jackson’s list
includes two cards from early in his career, a 1909 E90-1 American Caramel card
and a 1910 T210-8 card, plus the well-known 1914 Cracker Jack card.
Beckett’s “dream” cards for the other players include:
Cicotte: 1914 Cracker Jack #94
Felsch: 1916 M101-4
Gandil: 1914 Cracker Jack #39
McMullin: 1917 White Sox Team Issue
Risberg: 1916 Zeenut (Vernon Tigers)
Weaver: 1911 Zeenut (San Francisco Seals)
Williams: 1915 Zeenut (Salt Lake Bees)
The only set that features all eight Black Sox players is the 1917 White Sox “Team Issue” cards, produced by Davis Printing Works in Chicago and sold as a complete boxed set by the team. The cards feature full-length, black-and-white photos of the players on a light background, with the player’s name and position underneath. Only one original set is known to exist, according to the late baseball card historian Bob Lemke, and it was last sold in 2001 for more than $50,000. (A reprint set was issued in 1992 by card dealer Greg Manning, who had bought the original cards a year earlier.)
Many of the cards in Beckett’s list are from the same
M101-4 and M101-5 sets issued in 1916, but they each feature different business
names on the back, from The Sporting News to the Weil Baking Company. Chicago-based
printer Felix Mendelsohn produced these sets of cards and took out an ad in The
Sporting News to sell space on the cardbacks to other businesses. TSN
began offering the cards with their own company information stamped on the back
later that summer. Six of the eight Black Sox (all except McMullin and
Williams) were included in the Mendelsohn card sets.
While a majority of these cards may remain out of reach
for even the most dedicated Black Sox collector, the list compiled by Beckett
should be a useful resource for years to come.
Periodically, I have added commemorative team sets to my collection. The sets may mark a championship year or other noteworthy occurrence, famous or infamous. Additionally, sets are issued to celebrate an anniversary year or a players’ reunion. For example, I did a blog post on cards given to attendees of a banquet honoring the 1969 Senators. Although this may prompt some of you to cancel your SABR membership, I will post additional pieces on commemorative sets from time-to-time.
First up is a 1988 set issued by Domino’s Pizza that commemorates the 20th anniversary of the Tigers 1968 World Series Championship. Most of you remember that Detroit bested St. Louis in a classic seven-game series. This World Series resonates with me since it is the first that I remember watching on TV.
All the photos in the 28-card set are black and white. Many of the shots are unfamiliar to me, which
was part of the appeal-along with being cheap.
All the unnumbered cards have a synopsis of the season printed on the
back along with the players’ 1968 regular season and World Series stats.
The cards were given away at Tiger Stadium during an “Old
Timers” game featuring the ’68 Tigers players. It is possible that they were also available
at Domino’s locations. Perhaps a Tiger
fan in my vast readership remembers.
Of course, I must include the cards of Ray Oyler and Wayne
Comer. Both players were selected in the
expansion draft by the Seattle Pilots after the World Series. You may recall that the light hitting Oyler
was benched in the World Series, with outfielder Mickey Stanley moving into the
shortstop slot. Both Comer and Oyler have
memorable turns in Jim Bouton’s Ball Four.
Two Tigers icons-Willie Horton and “Swingin’” Gates Brown-are
caught “in action.” Willie was the big
offensive force for the “Motor City Kitties” in 1968.
Speaking of icons, casual fan may not remember that
Hall-of-Fame member, Eddie Mathews, closed out his career in a limited role with
the Tigers in 1968.
The other Hall-of-Famer in the set is, of course, Al
Kaline. The all-time great is honored
with two cards. Ironically in Al’s only
championship season, he suffered a broken arm after being hit by a Lew Krausse
pitch, missing three months.
1968 was the “Year of the Pitcher” and Denny McLain was
instrumental in creating this designation.
Fueled by endless bottles of Pepsi, Denny won an astonishing 31 games on
his way to the AL Cy Young and MVP awards.
Another great Tiger hurler who came up big in the World
Series was Mickey Lolich. The portly “twirler”
won three games in the World Series, including a decisive seventh game victory
over Bob Gibson.
Although the Tigers rarely made errors in ’68, there are two error cards in this set. Pitcher Pat Dobson has a version with the photo showing Jon Warden (card on right). Additionally, leadoff man Dick McAualiffe has a version that leaves off the “e” from the end of his name.
I will end my Motown meanderings now, since I’m sure you are wishing that I was “looooong gone!” Plus, I need to go to the Tiger Stadium concession stand and redeem this Domino’s coupon.
A very long time ago I saw a comedian who found it funny to give people lotto tickets as gifts. Because the chance of winning was so remote, he quipped that the gesture was akin to giving someone “nothing.”
From 2003 through 2008, the Chicago Cubs held promotional dates in which prizes were given to a select few fans at several ballgames, typically no more than 100-500 of each. Although the chances of winning the prizes—autographed baseballs, jerseys, gloves, bats, and other sweet items—were slim, the Cubs did offer a bit of a consolation prize, at least for baseball card collectors, which was certainly better than nothing.
In 2003, the Cubs promotional schedule included 11 dates in which the giveaway was an official Rawlings baseball autographed by one of several players, such as Sammy Sosa, Ernie Banks, Billy Williams or Corey Patterson. The giveaway, however, was limited to 500 and given only to winners of a scratch-off game. All fans were given a game card, which was essentially a cool, though oddly sized, card for the player whose prize was being awarded that day. These cards measure 2” x 4” and are all set in a horizontal format.
On June 5, 2003, the Tampa Bay Devil Rays faced the Cubs at Wrigley Field for the rubber match of the three-game series. Paid attendance for the game was 28,713 and the Cubs were giving away 500 baseballs autographed by Ryne Sandberg that afternoon. Fans were given cards that featured a photo of Ryno superimposed on a sun swept Wrigley day; to the right was a shimmering golden scratch-off circle. The back of the card listed Sandberg’s career statistics and the sweepstakes’ entry rules. By my math, the chance of winning that day one was roughly 1.7%, without accounting for unused tickets and others who may have taken advantage of the “no purchase necessary” entry method, and assuming the game cards were distributed to all who attended. Not surprisingly, I was not a winner.
The Cubs ramped up the promotion in 2004, issuing a total of 21 cards and offering both autographed baseballs and Mitchell & Ness Cooperstown Authentic Collection jerseys of players such as Andy Pafko (1945), Ernie Banks (1958), Bill Buckner (1978) and Greg Maddux (2002). On September 29, the Cubs lost the Reds in twelve innings. I did not win a baseball autographed by Ron Santo.
In 2005, the Cubs issued the largest set yet, ballooning to 27 cards and peppering the giveaways with Wilson A2000 gloves, signed photos and Mitchell & Ness jerseys for Cubs legends Hack Wilson (1930), Gabby Hartnett (1938) and Bruce Sutter (1979).
The Cubs scaled back slightly in 2006 with 25 cards, but continued to offer fantastic prizes, which included catcher’s mitts signed by Michael Barrett, official bases signed by Ernie Banks and Ron Santo, and a helmet signed by Aramis Ramirez. They also offered jerseys of Babe Ruth, Jackie Robinson and Roberto Clemente. (Unfortunately, it appears as though the game cards for these non-Cub legends may have featured only a photo of the jersey, not the person.) Some of the game cards in 2006 went full postcard size at 4” x 6.” On May 27 the Braves beat the Cubs 2-1. I did not win a Derrick Lee autographed baseball.
The Cubs cut the giveaway promotion by over half in 2007, issuing only 12 cards and scaling back the prizes. They also did not bother providing any statistics on the flipside. On June 29 the Cubs beat the Brewers but, not shockingly, I did not leave with a photo signed by Alfonso Soriano.
The last hurrah for the promotion was in 2008, when the Cubs held just five giveaway dates. Perhaps the Cubs learned that giving away prizes to so few was not a great way to attract fans. Or maybe the players were simply fed up with having to sign so many things.
Through the years, it was not uncommon to see the losing cards folded on the ground or tossed in the garbage bins. Although there were presumably 30,000 to 35,000 of each of these cards manufactured, the number that survive at this point is appreciably thin, especially in good condition.
Overall, the Cubs issued 101 player cards, including one for the 1908 Cubs infield featuring the famous trio of Frank Chance, Johnny Evers and Joe Tinker, along with oft-forgotten third baseman Harry Steinfeldt. By my count, Derrick Lee and Ron Santo appeared on the most cards with eight. The winning cards were hole punched and returned to the winner with the prize. Accordingly, there are at least two versions (winner/loser) for each card, if you are into variations!
Completing the entire six-year run of these cards would be a daunting task. The cards are not numbered, apart from the serial number on the face of the card, and there is no hobby consensus as to what to call them. Some sellers label these card as a stadium giveaway (“SGA”), which is appropriate—though not fully accurate—in that these were not the giveaway, just a means to randomly distribute the giveaway. It does not appear that these cards are terribly plentiful—either scanned or for sale.
A full checklist can be found here, showing the date of each card giveaway and the prize offered. A second list shows the number of cards for each individual.
The past couple of seasons Minor League Baseball has been running a Copa de Diversión promotion which involves rebranding teams with Spanish nicknames and uniforms. My kids really wanted to go to a Trenton Trueno game and due to a rainout at one of the Kids Club games we were able to go while only having to pay for parking.
Anyway, while we went for the Trueno experience, it turned out that it was also a baseball card giveaway night. We each got perforated strips of four cards (plus an advertisement) featuring four current Yankees who’d played for Trenton and who were also Latino—Andújar, Severino, and Sánchez are from the Dominican Republic while Torres is from Venezuela.
The cards are manufactured by Choice—the same company that makes Trenton’s Minor League team sets—and, aside from the perforations are legitimate cards rather than something that feels like a cheap digitally-printed sheet. The only problem is that the cards were designed with bleeds but whoever laid them out for perfing didn’t take that into account so the three center cards in the panel are closer to 2.625 inches wide.
Still it’s a fun little set with photos of the guys while they were at Trenton, nice Trueno logos, and some #PonleAcento action. I’m a bit confused at how Andújar got the accent and Sánchez did not though.
The back design is also nicely bilingual. The positions and vitals information are still English-only but the biographies allocate equal space to both languages. It does kind of feel like they were written in English and then translated semi-literally to Spanish but it’s a solid effort.
Since this set isn’t entered to Trading Card DB yet I have no idea how many other Minor League teams released cards as part of the Copa de Diversión. But it’s pretty cool and is a great recognition that not only is the game-day experience something that should be inclusive to Spanish-speaking fans, the merchandise and giveaways should also accessible to as many fans as possible.
With SABR 49 about to unfold in beautiful San Diego, I offer
a look at Padres’ cards from the Pacific Coast League era, which ends with the formation
of the Major League Padres in 1969.
The original Hollywood Stars moved to San Diego in 1936. The
city fathers constructed a wooden ballpark, Lane Field, near the train station
on the water front. From there, the team
would move into the Mission Valley in 1958 to play at Westgate Park and,
finally, San Diego Stadium in 1968.
According to PCL historian, collector and dealer Mark MacRae,
the first set of Padres collectibles were team issued photos in 1947. However, this set does not show up in the Standard
Catalog of Vintage Baseball Cards. This
publicity photo of manager “Ripper” Collins from 1947 may be an example, but
I’m by no means certain.
Two years later, Bowman issues a PCL set in the same format
as their MLB cards. The small, square
cards were issued in packs with a total of 32 in the set. The five Padres players are Xavier Rescigno
(pictured), John Jensen, Pete Coscavart, Lee Handley and Tom Seats. The cards were issued as reprint set in 1987
by the Card Collectors Company. The
reprints are distinguished by wider, white borders.
Bowman wasn’t the only company to issue PCL cards in 1949. The Hage’s Dairy company begins a three- year run with a 107-card set-with at least 26 different Padres. This initial set and the subsequent issues are filled with variation cards. Some players have up to four different poses. They were distributed in boxes of popcorn at Lane Field. Cards were added or removed when the rosters changed. The 1951 cards come in four different tones: sepia, blue, green and black-and-white. This set includes Luke Easter, manager Bucky Harris and John Ritchey, who broke the PCL color barrier in 1948.
Incidentally, the Bowman cards used many of the same photographs as Hage’s. For example, Bowman simply cropped this photo of John Jensen.
Hage’s comes back in 1950 with a 122-card set that has at
least 28 Padres. This time, all the cards are black-and-white. Also, Hage’s ice
cream is advertised on the back. This
set has manager Jimmy Reese as well as two variations of Orestes “Minnie”
Minoso. Among other recognizable names
are: Al Smith (famous for having beer poured on his head by fan in ’59 World
Series), Harry “Suitcase” Simpson, and Tom Tresh’s dad, Mike.
In 1951, Hage’s produces a much reduced 54-card set, with
all but 12 of them being Padres. The other cards are comprised of seven
Cleveland Indians and five Hollywood Stars. They were printed in the following
tints: blue, green, burgundy, gold, gray and sepia. Harry Malmberg is an example of the many photo
variations. The two cards above are both
from 1951. Some familiar names in this
set are Ray Boone, Luke Easter and “Sad” Sam Jones.
Like an ice cream bar left in the warm California sun,
Hage’s Dairy cards melted away in 1952, leaving Globe Printing as the card
producer for the Padres. This 18-card,
black-and-white set features manager Lefty O’Doul, coach Jimmy Reese, Memo Luna
and Herb Gorman. I’m not sure how the
cards were distributed.
1952 is a big PCL card year-due to the introduction of the fabulous Mother’s Cookies set. The 64-card set was distributed in packages of cookies on the West Coast. Padres’ manager, Lefty O’Doul, has on a beautiful satin jacket in his photo. Some of the recognizable players include Memo Luna, “Whitey” Wietlemann and “Red” Embree.
Mother’s Cookies returns with a 63-card set in 1954. Of the seven Padres in the set, the most interesting is Tom Alston. He would integrate the St. Louis Cardinals in 1954 after being purchased for $100,000. Unfortunately, mental illness ended his promising career in 1957. Also, Lefty O’Doul is back, and former MLB player Earl Rapp has a card.
I was unable to locate any evidence of Padres cards from 1953-60, but in 1961 the fantastic Union Oil set showed up at West Coast 76 stations. The sepia tone cards measure 3”X 4” and featured 12 Padres. Among the players available are: Herb Score, Harry “Suitcase” Simpson, Mike Hershberger and Dick Lines.
The Major League Padres arrive in 1969, but cards from the PCL era would emerge in retrospective sets. In 1974, PCL historian and fan, Ed Broder, self-produced a 253-card set, modeled after the Seattle Rainiers popcorn cards. He used players from 1957-58. There are 31 Padres cards in the set, including future Seattle Pilot, Gary “Ding Dong” Bell, Bob Dipietro, and Jim “Mudcat” Grant.
Another retro set was produced by TCMA in 1975. The 18-card set has PCL players from the mid-1950s,
one of which is Padre Cal McLish. The cards are “tallboy” size-like early 1970s
In recent years, the late Carl Aldana self-produced several
Padres cards in the Mother’s Cookies format.
The players he chose are: Ted Williams, Luke Easter, Max West, Al Smith
and Jack Graham.
Please let me know if there are other years that PCL Padres
cards were produced or if you have a 1947 team issued photo.
SABR convention goers will assemble at glitzy Petco Park for
a Padres game against the Cardinals. Not too far away, a humbler structure once
stood, Lane Field. Though small and
termite infested, it was “big time” to fans in a simpler era with limited entertainment
At the game, I plan to buy a box of popcorn to see if a Hage’s Dairy Memo Luna card was magically inserted amongst the kernels.
At a recent card show, I purchased three Mother’s Cookies
team sets from the ‘80s. As far as “give-away” cards go, Mother’s Cookies are
near the top of the quality list. The
sharp photos on glossy stock combined with a simple design, featuring rounded
corners, produces a very attractive card.
The company produced team sets for the West Coast and Texas clubs during the ’80s and ’90s. The 28-card team sets were primarily composed of players from the year of issue. Sets, packed in envelopes, were given away at the stadium as promotions. Fans received approximately 90% of a set. Each envelope contained several duplicates to trade with other fans to secure the missing two or three cards. Additionally, an individual card from the local team was inserted into retail bags of cookies.
Mother’s Cookies used a different criterion for two of the
sets I picked up at the show. Both the
’86 Astros and the ’87 Athletics are All-Time, All-Star sets. One card was produced for the All-Star
representatives over the years. In
Houston’s case, it starts in ’62 with Dick “Turk” Farrell of the expansion Colt
.45’s. Oakland kicks off with Bert Campaneris in 1968-the year they moved from
The Astros cards are unique and quite striking in
appearance. Each card is a colorfully
painted portrait with stylized depictions. However, the artist* does an
excellent job of making the players recognizable. This is a great choice, since “photo realism”
would have made the whole exercise superfluous.
(*Richard-with a last name beginning with W-is the artist
signature. I was unable to identify
Houston’s colorful uniform history adds to the visual appeal. Starting with the wonderful Colt .45’s uniform, you see a progression to the “starburst” Astros, the primary color switch to orange, and finally the famous “Tequila Sunrise.”
Although the A’s didn’t use painted portraits, their colorful uniform history is on full display. Plus, the set has most of the principal players from the ’71-’75 dynasty era. The vest style uniforms give way to the polyester pullover jerseys and beltless pants in bold Kelly Green, California Gold and Wedding Gown White combinations.
The A’s set is from just before the “Bash Brothers” era, but
Jose Canseco shows up twice. Also, there
are cards from the lean years of the late ‘70s and the resurrection during the
“Billy Ball” era.
At five dollars per set, I couldn’t go wrong even if the
cards were less than stellar. So, I am very pleased with this purchase. By the way, the third set I bought is the ’84
Padres. This set is very colorful as
well with the NL champion Padres sporting the “chili dog” accent colors on the
I am sufficiently inspired to collect more of these
relatively inexpensive gems. Of course,
I have the complete Mariners run.
For those of us whose minds tend to gravitate toward the obscure and trivial, baseball cards can serve as a stimulate for this brain disorder. For example, the magic mushroom that sent me falling down the rabbit hole recently was a 1961 Seattle Rainiers’ popcorn card of Ted Schreiber.
I’ve had the card for several years, but recently purchased an off grade 8×10 glossy of the same photo as appears on the card. Curious to know more about Mr. Schreiber, I sought out online information on the infielder. Of course, it didn’t take the “men from to chessboard to tell me where to go.”
Since I couldn’t “go ask Alice,” The SABR Bioproject was my destination. Bioproject is an invaluable resource. The forgotten and obscure players are given the same scholarly treatment as the all-time greats. Mr. Rory Costello’s biography of Schreiber is well written and provides some surprising information. After reading it, I felt like I was “given the call” to tell you about Mr. Schreiber, aided by a look at his few, but wonderful, cards. By the way, Topps never issued a card for him.
Though no “Red Queen” ever tried to “off” Schreiber’s head, he did make “off” from his Brooklyn home in the late 1950’s destined for Queens-where he donned the “red” of the St.John’s Redmen. Ted played basketball for legendary coach Joe Lapchick and baseball for long-time coach, Jack Kaiser. Since my son graduated from St. John’s, I’ve developed an interest in the school’s sports history. This connection heightened my interest in Schreiber’s story.
Mr. Costello’s biography provided a great piece of trivia. Ted hit two home runs at Ebbets Field in 1959. Turns out, St. John’s played three home games there against Manhattan College.
Schrieber’s exploits on the diamond for the Redmen drew the attention of scout Frank “Bots” Nakola. If your “mind is moving low” and this name doesn’t ring a bell, he is the Red Sox scout who signed Yaz, Rico Petrocelli and Chuck Schilling out of the New York area. After a workout at Fenway Park, Ted signed with Boston.
In 1961 and 1962, Ted played in Seattle-the Red Sox AAA affiliate in the Pacific Coast League. From 1954 to 1968, the Rainiers/Angels issued smallish, glossy cards in boxes of popcorn. For reasons unknown, there are two variations of Schreiber cards in both 1961 and 1962. The 1961 “action” card misspelled Ted’s name. If you want to know more about popcorn cards, here are links to my previous posts
During the off season, the Mets selected Schreiber in the Rule 5 draft. Since his route to Boston was blocked by second sacker, Chuck Schilling, this was a good break for Ted. However, Ron Hunt won the starting job at second base for the Mets. As a bench player Schreiber appeared in only 39 games, but he did take center stage in a piece of Mets history.
On September 26, 1963, Ted pinch hit for his old St. John’s teammate, Larry Bearnath. He promptly hit into a game ending double play, thus making the last out in the history of the Polo Grounds. Though Topps never produced a card for Schreiber, there is a team issued photo from 1963.
Returning to the minors in 1964, Schreiber would never make back to the “show.” His one year in the “bigs” secured a card in Larry Fritsch’s 1983 “One Year Wonders” set. Also, Ted shows up in the 1966 Elder Postcards, 1976 SSPC set commemorating the ’63 Mets and in the 1971 “Wiz” Mets set.
Since “logic and proportion has fallen sloppy dead,” and you would rather hear “the White Knight talking backwards” than continue with me chasing rabbits, I will stop. But remember what the Bobby “Doerr-mouse” said: “Feed your head” with Bioproject.
The 2006 SABR convention in Seattle featured Jim Bouton as part of a lively Seattle Pilots panel. Jim told a story about meeting his old Pilots teammate, Tommy Davis, years after the infamous ’69 season. Jim revealed that Tommy looked at him, shook his head and said, “what a bunch of mutts.”
This is an apt description of the expansion teams prior to the free agency era. The new clubs were an assortment of veterans past their prime, players with marginal skills or unproven rookies. I have identified eight players who had the misfortune of playing on two different first-year expansion teams. Here are their “cardboard” stories.6
The first man to experience this dubious “double play” was pitcher Hal Woodeshick. The new Washington Senators acquired Hal from the old Senators (Minnesota Twins) in the expansion draft prior to the ’61 campaign. His tenure in DC was short lived, as the Senators sold him to the Tigers during the ’61 season. Subsequently, “Suitcase Hal” was sold to the new Colt .45’s in the winter of ’61. All this coming and going must have induced a sense of paranoia in Hal, as these two photos clearly document.6
Any Seattle baseball fan worth his or her salt knows that Diego Segui pitched for both the Pilots and Mariners. Diego was the most effective hurler for the ill-fated ‘69 Pilots and the opening day starter for the Mariners. The eight-year gap between Seattle appearances saw the erosion of Segui’s skills. He posted an 0-7 record and was released at the conclusion of the season.
I have always been intrigued by Diego’s ’77 card. Why is he wearing a Red Sox batting helmet-since the AL used the DH and Diego was a relief pitcher?6
Merritt Ranew is another Pilot with a resume that included two first-year expansion team stints. The ’62 Houston Colt ‘45’s drafted the young receiver from the Braves. His ’62 rookie card is an airbrushed gem. Despite Topps’ assertion on the back that Merritt “can’t miss,” most of his career was spent in the minors. Topps didn’t produce a card for him in ’69, his last season in the majors. The ‘83 Renata Galasso Pilots retrospective set does include Merritt. The back of the card states that Ranew was the only Pilot who played on two first year expansion clubs. This is incorrect.6
Ranew had a teammate that played on both the ’62 Colt ‘45s and the Pilots: George Brunet. The “flaky” lefthander was drafted from the Braves by Houston. Topps didn’t produce a ’62 card for George, but he does have a ’63. Brunet joined the Pilots in July after his release from the Angels. No Pilots card was ever produced. Very few images exist of George as a Pilot. Here is a custom card-using a poorly colorized publicity still-of the happy-go-lucky, “underwear-averse” journeyman. 6
The beloved and inept ’62 Mets picked up catcher Chris Cannizzaro from St. Louis in the expansion draft. He shuttled between AAA and the majors for most of the ‘60s before resurfacing with he infant San Diego Padres in ’69, after a trade with Pittsburgh. Cannizzaro became the starting catcher and was Padres’ lone All-Star representative. Topps issued a card of Chris on the Pirates in 69, thus ’70 is his first on the San Diego.6
Chris’ ’62 Mets teammate, Galen Cisco, found himself on the roster of the ‘newbie” Royals in ‘69. Galen’s ’62 card has him on the Red Sox, since he was purchased by the Mets late in the season. However, he does get a New York card in ’63.
Perhaps the best player of this unique group is Ron Fairly. The steady-if not spectacular-Fairly was dealt by the Dodgers to Montreal for Maury Wills in June of ’69. Expos’ fans had to wait until ’70 to collect his card on Montreal. Ron continued a successful career in the ‘70s, eventually ending up in ’76 with the A’s. In the off season, Fairly was traded to the Blue Jays, but not before Topps issued a ’77 card depicting him on Oakland. With the ’77 expansion Blue Jays, Ron had an excellent season as the DH. He served as Toronto’s first all-star selection and got a Blue Jays’ card in ‘78. 9
The only duel expansionist I can identify for the last wave of expansion in the ‘90s is Scott Aldred. The lefty pitched in five games for the ’93 Rockies and made 48 appearances for the ’98 Devil Rays. Apparently, Scott didn’t receive a ’98 or ’99 card. So, this team generated photo serves as proof that he did toil in the “Trop.”
I would be remiss if I didn’t mention a player who almost joined this group of vagabonds. Jeff Katz’s (@SplitSeason1981) old insurance man, Marv Staehle, was in spring training with the Pilots. He was sent to AAA Vancouver and later traded to the Expos. Marv played in six games for Montreal in ’69.
20 years have past since the last expansion. It is safe to say that this exclusive club will remain as is, until MLB once again expands at least twice within a ten-year span.
If you unearth another player who saw action for two first-year expansion clubs, let me know. It is entirely possible I missed some unfortunate soul.
The ‘70’s were a wasteland for cards. There simply wasn’t a lot of product, especially not compared to the flood soon to come. (Après moi le deluge indeed!) So when Burger King issued Yankees cards in 1977, it was a big deal, such a big deal for me that I didn’t have the set. Not only didn’t I have the set, but I didn’t have a single card.
Why? I can’t quite figure that one out. I was collecting seriously, and in 1978 and 1979, I finished complete BK Yankees sets with doubles to spare. The 1977 cards passed me by and I don’t understand it to this day.
Some background info (from the Standard Catalog):
The first Topps-produced set for Burger King restaurants was issued in the New York area, featuring the A.L. champion Yankees. Twenty-two players plus an unnumbered checklist were issued at the beginning of the promotion with card #23 (Lou Piniella) being added to the set later. The “New York Post” reported production of the first 22 player cards at about 170,000 of each. The Piniella card was issued in limited quantities. Cards are 2-1/2″ x 3-1/2″ and have fronts identical to the regular 1977 Topps set except for numbers 2, 6, 7, 13, 14, 15, 17, 20 and 21. These cards feature different poses or major picture-cropping variations. It should be noted that very minor cropping variations between the regular Topps sets and the Burger King issues exist throughout the years the sets were produced.
Here are the variations, regular Topps on the left, Burger King on the right.
No All-Star banner. Burger King is an egalitarian enterprise.
Better cap, same puzzled look.
Nice to see Torrez in an airbrushed Yankee cap, but he’s still stuck in the Coliseum. Updated card, though not a better one.
NEVER play without a cup!
Bucky gets two great cards in ’77.
No point in the difference in cropping. The Topps card is nicer, with more of the new stadium in view.
The Topps issue for Reggie that year is one of the worst cards for a marquee player. The Burger King card remedies that, and shows Jax looking a bit nervous in NY. Airbrushed Reggie seems more cocky.
You’d think The Toy Cannon would be happier moving from the Braves to the Yankees. Doesn’t seem like it.
Good cards, same backdrop. Key detail – Yankees don’t choke up!
#23 of a 22 card set.
At the time, the story about the Piniella card was that George Steinbrenner, always used to having things his way, was incensed that Lou, a personal favorite and Tampa native, was passed over in the initial run. Besides the typical Boss tirade, it is odd. Piniella was certainly more important to the team at the time than Paul Blair or Jimmy Wynn.
I bring this set up because my 40+ years of drought has ended. I picked up a beautiful set this week, with Piniella. It makes me very happy to have them in hand after all these years.